Bennett's Bluff on James Island, SC

New Homes Built by Toll Brothers

Bennett’s Bluff is the newest neighborhood on James Island. Developed by the builder Toll Brothers, this waterfront community offers a dock on Clark Sound and is ranked for fantastic public schools (Stiles Point Elementary, Camp Road Middle, and James Island Charter High).

The Firethorn floor plan which serves as the model is a nearly perfect design because it has the features that almost every buyer seems to want (plus some extras): open floor plan, huge downstairs master, downstairs home office, upstairs/secondary den, screened porch capability, and a butler’s pantry leading to the separate dining room. With 10 other floor plans to choose from, buyers can find a good modern layout with plenty of square footage. We’re happy to show you both pre-owned homes and new construction currently being built by Toll Brothers, so contact us to see all of your options. Since we live and work on James Island, we often hear about existing home listings before they hit the MLS, so we are happy to do some digging to find what you’re looking for!

Bennett's Bluff Real Estate Statistics

Total Listings: 1
Average Price: $1,450,000
Highest Listing Price: $1,450,000
Average Days On Website: 35
Average Price/SqFt: $572

Roll over thumbnail to enlarge.

Bennett’s Bluff Pros:

  • The newest of James Island neighborhoods
  • Ideal for buyers wanting a waterfront lifestyle close to Downtown
  • Excellent public schools
  • Fantastic selection of floor plans and finishes

Bennett’s Bluff Cons:

  • Located behind a city soccer complex, so no direct entrance off Fort Johnson Road
  • Heavier traffic during high school drop off/pick up times (located within walking distance)

Homes for Sale in Bennett's Bluff

Price, Low to High
1 Properties Found.

1574 Charming Nancy Road

$1,450,000
MLS® #26019683

Bennetts Bluff
James Island, SC
4 BR, 3½ BA, 2533 SQ FT, 0.25 ACRES
Built in 2023
House

Experience the perfect blend of Lowcountry elegance and modern luxury in this exceptional custom home, built jus…

Living on James Island, SC: What's Nearby?

Recently Sold Bennett's Bluff Homes

Price, Low to High
4 Properties Found.
Photo of Listing #26004970

1439 Rivers Cotton Road

$1,070,000
MLS® #26004970

Bennetts Bluff
James Island, SC
4 BR, 3½ BA, 2936 SQ FT, 0.22 ACRES
Built in 2020
House

Tucked away just off Fort Johnson Road on James Island, 1439 Rivers Cotton Road offers the rare blend of peacefu…

Photo of Listing #25027286

1522 Charming Nancy Road

$1,085,000
MLS® #25027286

Bennetts Bluff
James Island, SC
4 BR, 3½ BA, 3026 SQ FT, 0.21 ACRES
Built in 2021
House

Welcome to 1522 Charming Nancy Road, a beautifully crafted home in the coveted Bennetts Bluff community on James…

Photo of Listing #26004524

1427 Rivers Cotton Road

$1,200,000
MLS® #26004524

Bennetts Bluff
James Island, SC
5 BR, 3½ BA, 3434 SQ FT, 0.21 ACRES
Built in 2021
House

Welcome to 1427 Rivers Cotton Road! This stunning custom built 5 Bed/3.5 Bath Prescott floor plan property offer…

Photo of Listing #26011708

1171 Elliotts Cut Drive

$1,367,500
MLS® #26011708

Bennetts Bluff
James Island, SC
5 BR, 3½ BA, 3623 SQ FT, 0.22 ACRES
Built in 2021
House

Saltwater pool, hot tub, and screened porch create a private backyard oasis in this move-in ready Lansford home!…

More James Island Neighborhoods

James Island Real Estate

James Island Houses

Questions about James Island Real Estate?

Contact The Keadle Group online or call/text 843.847.0239 for help!

Contact The Keadle Group

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker ReciprocitySM Program of the Charleston Trident Multiple Listing Service. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Carolina One Real Estate are marked with the Broker ReciprocitySM logo or the Broker ReciprocitySM thumbnail logo (a little black house) and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers.

The broker providing these data believes them to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm them before relying on them in a purchase decision.

Copyright 2026 Charleston Trident Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.