This home has now sold. Contact us if you’d like to see similar properties!
  • $2,390,000

    ($6,638.89/mo.)
    • 5
    • 5609
    • 0.17
  • House
  • MLS® #: 26008059
  • Days on Website: 142
  • 2431 Settlers Street

  • Charleston, SC 29492
  • Daniel Island Smythe Park

  • MLS® 26008059 is located at 2431 Settlers Street in Daniel Island, SC. This house offers 5 bedrooms, 5.5 baths, and is 5609 square feet.

Some homes are defined by their finishes. Others by how life unfolds within them. In a quiet, highly sought-after section of Daniel Island where homes rarely becomeavailable, this custom Lowcountry residence offers a level of privacy, walkability, anddaily ease that is increasingly difficult to find. Less than a block from top-ranked schools and minutes to Charleston International Airport, the home pairs a refined layout withseamless indoor-outdoor living and a fully private third-floor suite for extended stays or evolving needs. It is a setting designed for those who value time, discretion, and a lifethat moves effortlessly between obligation and retreat. Set within one of the most established and tightly held enclaves of the Island, this residence occupies a position where... the island feels at its most complete--mature tree- lined streets, immediate access to water and parks, and a sense of quiet continuity that newer sections have yet to replicate. Opportunities here are limited, and ownership tends to be long-term. Mornings begin without urgency. Light moves across the Wando River as the island wakes slowly--footsteps along shaded trails, the sound of water at Smythe Lake, children walking to school just a block away. There is no need to coordinate the day around traffic or distance; everything essential is already integrated. Within minutes, you are connected to shopping, Charleston International Airport and the region's primary business corridors, yet the return home feels distinctly removed--private, settled, and controlled. Originally built by custom homebuilder Ryan Butler as a personal residence, the home reflects a level of intention rarely seen in speculative construction. As you tour the home, take a moment to appreciate the quality of the finishes. There's a discernable difference between this and other homes, the solidity you feel is real. The architecture is grounded in proportion and flow rather than excess--formal and informal spaces aligned along a central axis, with French doors opening to a full-length front porch that captures coastal breezes and extends living outward. The kitchen, supported by a true butler's pantry, anchors the home for both daily use and larger gatherings, while the screened porch and outdoor living area--with fire feature and integrated cooking space--create a setting where evenings naturally extend. Upstairs, the owner's retreat is positioned for privacy and light, with a terrace that receives the first hours of the day. The bath and dressing room are designed with clarity and functionality. Additional spacious ensuite rooms provide separation and comfort, while a fully independent third-floor suite offers flexibility that adapts over time--whether for extended family, guests, or a more private arrangement within the home. Several home-office opportunities provide independent spaces for one to three home offices. What distinguishes this property further is not only the home itself, but how it sits within the island. Over 25 miles of trails, waterfront parks, a world-class tennis facility, a marina and open green space are accessed without planning--they are simply part of the day. Membership opportunities at Daniel Island Club extend the experience with golf, tennis, and dining set against the marsh and river, where availability remains limited and highly competitive. Equally important is what this setting avoids. There is no dependence on long drives for routine life, and none of the constraints often associated with more urban historic properties. Movement is simple. Time is preserved. The environment remains consistent. 2431 Settlers Street is not defined by scale alone, but by alignment, location, design, and daily function working together without compromise. It is a home that holds its value not only in what it offers today, but in how effortlessly it supports what comes next. We invite you to experience it in person--and discover a place where life feels both elevated and entirely your own.

Essential Information

  • MLS® #26008059
  • Sale Price$2,390,000
  • List Price$2,495,000
  • Bedrooms5
  • Full Baths5
  • Half Baths1
  • Square Footage5,609
  • Acres0.17
  • Year Built2007
  • TypeHouse

Style

Contemporary, Live/Work, Traditional

Community Information

  • Address2431 Settlers Street
  • SubdivisionDaniel Island Smythe Park
  • CityCharleston
  • CountyBerkeley
  • StateSC
  • Zip Code29492

Area

77 - Daniel Island

Amenities

  • # of Garages2

Neighborhood Amenities

Clubhouse, Club Membership Available, Dock Facilities, Dog Park, Fitness Center, Golf Course, Marina, Park, Pool, Tennis Court(s), Trash, Walk/Jog Trails

Utilities

Charleston Water Service, Dominion Energy

Parking

2 Car Garage, Attached, Off Street, Garage Door Opener

Interior

  • HeatingForced Air
  • CoolingCentral Air
  • FireplaceYes
  • # of Fireplaces2
  • # of Stories3
  • Stories3 Stories

Interior Features

Ceiling - Smooth, High Ceilings, Garden Tub/Shower, Kitchen Island, Walk-In Closet(s), Bonus, Eat-in Kitchen, Family, Formal Living, Entrance Foyer, Game, Great, Loft, Media, In-Law Floorplan, Office, Pantry, Separate Dining, Study, Utility

Fireplaces

Family Room, Gas Log, Living Room, Two, Wood Burning

Exterior

  • ExteriorCement Siding
  • Lot Description0 - .5 Acre, High, Level
  • RoofArchitectural, See Remarks

Exterior Features

Balcony, Lawn Irrigation, Outdoor Kitchen

Windows

Thermal Windows/Doors, Window Treatments

School Information

  • ElementaryDaniel Island
  • MiddleDaniel Island
  • HighPhilip Simmons

Additional Information

  • Days on Website142
  • Office: Exp Realty Llc

Aerial View/Directions

Birdseye View

Please provide a valid email address.

Active Listings Similar to 2431 Settlers Street

Photo of Listing #26021314

1409 Hooper Street

$2,445,000

8 Bed, 7 Bath, 4049 Sqft, 0.19 Acres
Daniel Island Smythe Park
Charleston, SC
Carolina One Real Estate

Photo of Listing #26022242

1483 Wando Landing Street

$1,850,000

5 Bed, 4½ Bath, 3493 Sqft, 0.19 Acres
Daniel Island Smythe Park
Charleston, SC
Realty One Group Coastal

Photo of Listing #26020592

1675 Pierce Street

$1,850,000

5 Bed, 4½ Bath, 3000 Sqft, 0.2 Acres
Daniel Island
Daniel Island, SC
Carolina One Real Estate

Photo of Listing #26018996

1105 Barfield Street

$2,100,000

5 Bed, 4 Bath, 3687 Sqft, 0.31 Acres
Daniel Island
Daniel Island, SC
Matt O'neill Real Estate

Photo of Listing #26016427

327 Simone Drive Lot 49

$2,495,000

5 Bed, 4 Bath, 3436 Sqft, 0.14 Acres
The Marshes at Daniel Island
Charleston, SC
Carolina One Real Estate

Photo of Listing #26019064

227 Palmetto Bluff

$1,995,000

5 Bed, 4½ Bath, 3489 Sqft, 0.33 Acres
Grassy Creek
Mount Pleasant, SC
The Boulevard Company

Recently Sold Listings Similar to 2431 Settlers Street

Photo of Listing #26020909

2402 Settlers Street

$2,400,000

5 Bed, 4½ Bath, 4376 Sqft, 0.28 Acres
Daniel Island
Daniel Island, SC

Photo of Listing #25027641

2393 Daniel Island Drive

$2,200,000

5 Bed, 5½ Bath, 4768 Sqft, 0.3 Acres
Daniel Island
Charleston, SC

Photo of Listing #26003443

1250 Smythe Street

$1,850,000

4 Bed, 3½ Bath, 3707 Sqft, 0.16 Acres
Daniel Island Smythe Park
Charleston, SC

Photo of Listing #25019151

2449 Daniel Island Drive

$2,075,000

5 Bed, 5½ Bath, 3564 Sqft, 0.22 Acres
Daniel Island Smythe Park
Daniel Island, SC

Photo of Listing #25027526

1119 Oak Overhang Street

$2,500,000

4 Bed, 3½ Bath, 3585 Sqft, 0.34 Acres
Daniel Island
Charleston, SC

Photo of Listing #25032536

1239 Smythe Street

$1,925,000

5 Bed, 4 Bath, 2912 Sqft, 0.32 Acres
Daniel Island
Charleston, SC

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker ReciprocitySM Program of the Charleston Trident Multiple Listing Service. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Carolina One Real Estate are marked with the Broker ReciprocitySM logo or the Broker ReciprocitySM thumbnail logo (a little black house) and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers.

The broker providing these data believes them to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm them before relying on them in a purchase decision.

Copyright 2026 Charleston Trident Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.